Thursday, September 15, 2005

Where is the Australia we know ?

Where is the Australia we know? To deem that the way Australia have played during this Ashes to be purely a result of being up against a better team, would be gross injustice to the efforts of Allan Border, Mark Taylor and Steve Waugh in building a clinical and ruthlessly efficient winning machine. They nurtured a team that was tough, relentless and competitive to the point of being called unsporting. In fact, they secretly considered being disliked a compliment.

Australia have had a succession of brilliant captains and after the tough-as-nails Steve Waugh the mantle fell on Ricky Ponting’s shoulders. Perhaps the administrators choice was swayed by Ponting’s rough and tough demeanour. A ruthless and accomplished batsmen, Ponting had a reputation of being a tough bloke and it’s entirely conceivable that the men who mattered thought his maverick attitude would extend to his leadership as well. Whether John Buchanan’s methodic and scientific approach has curbed Ponting’s natural instincts or whether Ponting was never a leader of men, one thing is certain; this Australian team lacked the tenacity needed when it mattered most; an Australian trademark in previous years. Let this not take away anything from the character that Shane Warne and Glenn McGrath have shown through out this England summer. They are champions and have proved themselves again. But cricket is a team game and with McGrath injured, it was beyond Warne to win it single-handedly for Australia. Though he did come close.

Ponting inherited a winning team from Steve Waugh and continued in the same vein for several years. He led successful campaigns in several countries and even claimed a World Cup triumph. But there was one crucial difference; Taylor and Waugh were raw when Australia underwent a transformation under Border; a mediocre team became one that could hold their own. They witnessed the change and knew how and why it had come about; they were still young when the term ‘mental disintegration’ came to be. They were richer for the experience and used it to take Australia to dizzying heights. Ponting was new to the experience of losing a series as captain, let alone the Ashes.

Leadership is best tested in adversity and this is where Ricky Ponting’s captaincy was severely exposed. His vent of frustration as Gary Pratt, the 12th man, ran him out told the world that England’s tactics has got under his skin; something Steve Waugh would have hidden even if it had had the same effect on him. And certainly one would never have dreamt of Waugh, for that matter any mature captain, saying that it was not his fault alone if the Ashes were lost, as Ponting did with one Test left to play. It was an astonishing admission of defeat and lack of faith in the team. Not to mention a dearth of self belief.

Perhaps the most significant difference between Ricky Ponting’s Australia and Steve Waugh’s Australia is the dulling of the killer instinct that Australia had honed to perfection under Waugh. Even though England were by far the better side, Australia had more than a couple of chances to commit day-light robbery and under Steve Waugh they just might have pulled it off. To question the fighting spirit of Warne, McGrath and Lee would be a terrible injustice but one cannot help but think that the Australia of the Taylor-Waugh era would have batted on in the fading light at The Oval instead of going off; fully aware that time was of the essence. That was the tough Australia, the Australia that produced the impossible when the impossible was called for. John Buchanan’s scientific and methodical strategies and plans can only do so much. To win when faced with the insurmountable, calls for special performances – extraordinary Human performances - in unfavourable and hopeless conditions and not procrastinations until the next day.

Waugh’s men may have lost at The Oval too, but his entire team, and not just a few individuals would have put their bodies on the line. And I would like to believe that when staring down the barrel of an inevitable defeat, Waugh would have urged his openers to stay out in the bad light and brave those final seven overs rather than accept defeat in the dressing room. It would have been gracious to give England their victory on the field and to go down with heads held high. Warne and McGrath shared Steve Waugh’s mindset of champions. And they certainly deserved better. One may argue that Ponting’s team is getting on in years. But McGrath started with buckets of wicket at Lord’s and Warne finished with 40 in the series. They are the oldest and most tired men in the side, but they were easily the best performers in the series. Perhaps Warne and McGrath refused to let Steve Waugh’s influence on them fade. By and large Ponting’s team is the same as Waugh’s. What has changed is the ethic.

But Ponting could not have hoped to continue winning forever. A defeat had to come sometime. And what this defeat has done is expose flaws that the past victories hid. These Ashes should not end Ponting's captaincy. It should provide the oppurtunity to correct the errors and come back stronger then ever.

23 Comments:

At 9:05 am, Blogger Yohan said...

Whoa. Despite everything, that was a scathing attack on Ponting.

I guess all things must pass, including Australia's invincibility.
(U.S Government take note, eh?)

Read this article.

Now we can look foward to England's tour of the subcontinent as eagerly as we used to look forward to the Aussies' tours.

 
At 11:00 pm, Blogger George said...

I dont think he should lose captaincy though. Everything is rosy when you win cos then your faults arent exposed. But Ponting made some huge blunders on this tour. And he wil;l do very well to learn from them.

 
At 4:32 am, Anonymous mysteryman said...

new post up on my blog..go chk it out..

 
At 8:18 am, Blogger Gautam Chandna said...

not that it would matter much.. but I forgive Ponting.

:-)

btw, did anyone see how drunk pieterson was when he met tony blair?

 
At 3:51 am, Blogger George said...

apparently they were served ionly pineapple juice and water at no. 10 downing street. someone put in a quite word and blair reluctantly brought out the scotch and some warm white wine.

 
At 3:56 am, Anonymous Murthy said...

Looking forward to those Bloody Poms coming to India, did someone say? Ha!

Sir Ashley is still their leading spinner, is he not?
And that Pieterson lad, does he not remember the fate that befell the last alcoholic-with-the-shocking-hairdo to stumble around our maidans (last heard, Funky Miller was coaching 'Katandra' in the something called 'The Shepparton Association Cricket League' - aka Auntie Philomena's Second XI)

Fine, so Freddie Flintoff is turning his arm over with a little purpose these days and he manages to keep his eyes open when he gives the little cherry the heave-ho. But, seriously, India?

Ladies and Gentlemen, exhibit A - The Spinner! A wily little customer, who causes much heartburn to most people unaccustomed to their skill, with a special distaste for people who drink tea, or beer, or both.

As the poet said:

"The Ashes will be The Ashes
For the urn is quite unique
But in the land of the puff of Dust
The Poms can kiss my left cheek."

 
At 5:24 am, Blogger Yohan said...

Murthy, Murthy, Murthy. Why don't you blog? You're a natural.

But right now the Indian team isn't quite the fleet-footed and fit army of professionals we used to know and love. Ahem.

 
At 10:53 pm, Blogger Vaibhav said...

"Where is the George we know?"

Happy belated birthday dude, i tried calling you up yesterday but your number was forwarding the call to another no. or some jazz...


PS: Yohan and Jakka totally forgot.. they were smoking up last night...

 
At 7:59 am, Blogger Yohan said...

NO we didn't. I messaged George. He was on roaming, so he must have gotten it.

Happy Birthday again then George!

 
At 3:03 am, Blogger lewisbrinick44069772 said...

Click Here Now Mortgage rates as low as 3.95%
$150,000 mortgage for $494/mo. Other loan amounts available. Up to 4 lenders in 24 hours.
Save money Click Here Now

 
At 11:41 pm, Blogger The_UndeaD_ said...

The Australia we know is on TV...or added to India every 6 years..or in South East Asia on the map...or in your heart my dear George. Please New Post.

 
At 7:34 pm, Blogger Editor said...

Hi, great site that you have here, i have a site that has everything on it that you would like to know about100mg viagra Be sure to check it out.

 
At 5:07 pm, Blogger Editor said...

The site thatyou are about to visit now has every info that you ever would need abouthow viagra works Be sure to check it out. Now over 17k visitors a day !

 
At 7:12 am, Blogger Ms. V said...

Where is the George we know???

 
At 1:46 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Choosing the right Bed: Bedcare
Proper care will keep your bed in good condition. Always read and retain manufacturers care instructions and ask your retailer for advice, too. Otherwise, the following tips will help you to get the best out of your bed during its natural life.
Use a washable, protective cover to protect the mattress (and pillows) from stains. Barrier fabrics for allergy sufferers are also available.
In the mornings, throw back the bed clothes and leave the bed to air for 20 minutes to allow body moisture to evaporate.
Turning your mattress over from side and side and end to end every few months (every week for the first three months) helps upholstery fillings to settle down more evenly. Some more luxurious mattresses, with much thicker layers of fillings designed to mould themselves to the contours of your body, may retain signs of these impressions, despite turning.
Don�t make a habit of sitting on the edge of the bed and don�t let the kids bounce on it.
Don�t roll up or squash a mattress to store or transport it - this can cause permanent damage.
Handles are designed to help you position a mattress on its base - do not use them to support the full weight of the mattress - they may pull out and damage the fabric.
Don�t leave polythene wrappings on a new mattress - dampness, mildew and rotting could all result from a build-up of condensation.
Vacuum your mattress and base from time to time to remove fluff and dust. This should be carefully done so as not to dislodge fillings or damage tufts. Open windows while vacuuming -especially if there is an asthma sufferer in the house.
When tackling stains, use mild detergent and warm or cold water. Never over soak a mattress or base.
Putting a new mattress on a base for which it was not intended, a new mattress on an old base or a board between the mattress and base can impede comfort and reduce the useful life of the mattress - as well as affecting any guarantees or warranties.
Out with the Old: Once you�ve bough yourself a new bed, make arrangements to have the old one disposed of (many retailers will do this for you). Don�t give it to the children, relatives, guests or neighbours. If it wasn�t good enough for you, it�s not good enough for anyone else, either. In fact, it�s a veritable health hazard - get rid of it
Definately something to think about if you plan to buy a
http://bedsforlessonline.co.uk

 
At 4:54 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

It used to be somewhere in the South-west of Asia... but due to continental drift since you asked, it might be anywhere by now...

 
At 6:05 am, Blogger PJ said...

hi george..i m sorry i had no other option...i m using the comments page to get in touch with you.i am an aspiring cricket journalist.me working for zee news at the news desk. can u gimme ur mail id. i have lots of queries and would be glad if u could help me out.
my name is vineet sharma
wacaperth@rediffmail.com

 
At 12:29 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice site!
[url=http://mmtnxdgs.com/xltg/ckze.html]My homepage[/url] | [url=http://tajqqyrg.com/etbj/pmxu.html]Cool site[/url]

 
At 12:29 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Great work!
My homepage | Please visit

 
At 12:30 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Well done!
http://mmtnxdgs.com/xltg/ckze.html | http://ypclfwgg.com/tgdr/kine.html

 
At 8:53 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Great site

http://home-forclosure.eticketsontime.com home forclosure
http://beaded-bracelet.eurocarexpert.com beaded bracelet
http://bathroom-lighting.casinogamefactory.com bathroom lighting
http://chicago-single.casinogamefactory.com chicago single
http://silk-scarf.eurocarexpert.com silk scarf
http://diet-points.asapdeals.com diet points
http://garden-furniture.boulevardprivates.com garden furniture
http://chicago-florist.kisswings.com chicago florist
http://tote-bag.eurocarexpert.com tote bag
http://cpa-course.lysog.info cpa course
http://folding-table.lysog.info folding table
http://replica-handbag.lysog.info replica handbag
http://altima-nissan.lysog.info altima nissan
http://gym-bag.malig.info gym bag
http://adhd-treatment.malig.info adhd treatment

Thanks.

 
At 3:13 pm, Blogger bernard n. shull said...

hi mate, this is the canadin pharmacy you asked me about: the link

 
At 6:56 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

top [url=http://www.c-online-casino.co.uk/]uk casino bonus[/url] coincide the latest [url=http://www.casinolasvegass.com/]online casino[/url] unshackled no deposit perk at the foremost [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]bay take note of casino
[/url].

 

Post a Comment

<< Home